Cover of Sam & Charlie get Gnarly · Volume 02

By Phil Stilwell

Sam & Charlie get Gnarly

Sam & Charlie get Gnarly · Volume 02

Ninety-six illustrated conversations about love, moral authority, reason, and certainty.

How much confidence should a belief receive—and what could make that confidence change?

A closer look

Words such as love, goodness, faith, and certainty can carry enormous weight. This second collection asks what those words actually tell us: what conduct love leads us to expect, what makes an authority trustworthy, and what distinguishes a confident interpretation from a well-supported conclusion.

Sam and Charlie are fictional companions inspired by Mark Twain and Charles Spurgeon. Charlie brings religious hope and a desire to trust; Sam asks for definitions, consistency, and reasons that someone outside the faith could examine. Their disagreement is the setting for the inquiry, rather than a substitute for it. A forceful reply still needs a sound argument, and a sincere conviction still leaves questions about how it was formed.

The four books in this volume

The Meaning of Divine Love tests descriptions of a loving God against suffering, violent commands, and the possibility of help. Comparisons with judges, surgeons, teachers, and neighbors ask which differences matter when an action is defended by authority or a hidden purpose. The question is not simply whether pain exists, but what warrants continuing confidence in the particular account of love being offered.

The Changing Moral Code examines biblical rules, exceptions, and changing practices. It distinguishes an unchanging principle from an instruction that must always remain identical. A defense of different commands therefore needs to show which relevant circumstances changed and how a stable principle accounts for both cases.

Belief in Proportion considers how confidence should respond when evidence changes. Maps, courts, manuals, and everyday purchases provide comparisons for discussing reliable guidance and the correction of mistakes. Faith understood as trust informed by experience is distinguished from confidence protected against every possible challenge.

The Feeling of Certainty separates the reality of a powerful experience from an explanation of its cause. Competing religious assurances, expectations, and the possibility of spiritual deception raise questions about how an experience identifies its own source. Naming an alternative explanation is not enough; the competing accounts still need to be assessed.

An illustrated argument you can pause

Books 05–08 contain ninety-six dialogues, accompanied by concise summaries. Introductions establish the questions behind each group of exchanges, while commentary and reflection questions encourage a slower second reading. The visual conversations give an argument a concrete setting; the surrounding discussion makes its assumptions and limits easier to inspect.

That discussion repeatedly asks for precision. Disagreement does not by itself disprove objective truth. A possible hidden purpose is not yet an established explanation. Respecting a person’s experience does not require accepting every account of what caused it. These distinctions keep the critique focused on what an argument actually supports.

For readers willing to test both sides

The collection suits readers who enjoy philosophical questions expressed through dialogue, including those examining religious commitments and those questioning skeptical arguments. It encourages a consistent standard: identify the claim, consider the relevant evidence, and ask what would count against your preferred explanation. The same questions apply to Sam’s confidence and to Charlie’s.

Ready to turn the page?

Find this book on Amazon